ESA assessments biased against mental health issues - courts

clock

The Court of Appeal has found the process deciding those eligible for Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) disadvantages people with mental health problems, learning disabilities and autism.

The case centres on how evidence is gathered for the Work Capability Assessment (WCA). Under the current system, evidence from a professional such as a GP or social worker is expected to be provided by claimants themselves.

There is no obligation for the DWP to collect this evidence, even on behalf of the most vulnerable, apart from in some rare cases.

Gathering evidence can be very challenging for people with mental health problems, learning disabilities or autism, resulting in them being assessed as fit for work.

The original judgment, in May this year, was the result of a Judicial Review brought by two anonymous claimants with mental health problems.

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) immediately appealed against the judgment and the Judicial Review was put on hold. Now that the DWP has lost their appeal, the Judicial Review will continue.

A final judgment is expected next year unless the DWP decide to take the case to the Supreme Court.

The charities Rethink Mental Illness, Mind and the National Autistic Society intervened in the case to provide evidence based on the experiences of their members and supporters.

In a joint statement Rethink Mental Illness, Mind and the National Autistic Society said: "The judges in the original ruling independently confirmed what our members and supporters have been saying for years - the system is unfair for some of the most vulnerable people in our society and is failing the very people it is meant to be supporting.

"In light of today's ruling it would be irresponsible for the DWP to carry on using these flawed assessments as they are."

More on Regulation

The COVER Review: A budget on the horizon, private healthcare and product launches

The COVER Review: A budget on the horizon, private healthcare and product launches

Week commencing 1 September 2025

COVER
clock 05 September 2025 • 1 min read
Autumn Budget 2025 set for 26 November

Autumn Budget 2025 set for 26 November

Investment and reform

Cameron Roberts
clock 03 September 2025 • 3 min read
The COVER Review: FCA updates, acquisitions and IPT

The COVER Review: FCA updates, acquisitions and IPT

Week commencing 25 August 2025

COVER
clock 29 August 2025 • 1 min read

Highlights

COVER Survey: Advisers damning of protection insurer service levels

COVER Survey: Advisers damning of protection insurer service levels

"It takes longer than ever to get underwriting terms"

John Brazier
clock 12 October 2023 • 5 min read
Online reviews trump price for young people selecting life and health cover

Online reviews trump price for young people selecting life and health cover

According to latest ReMark report

John Brazier
clock 11 October 2023 • 2 min read
ABI members with staff neurodiversity policy nearly doubles

ABI members with staff neurodiversity policy nearly doubles

Women within executive teams have grown to 32%

Jaskeet Briah
clock 10 October 2023 • 3 min read