PFS refused CII loan after Evelyn audit found 'significant' default risk

PFS member director hits back at CII governance failure claims

Jenna Brown
clock • 3 min read

The bitter dispute between the Personal Finance Society (PFS) and the Chartered Insurance Institute (CII) has taken another turn with the revelation that an audit by Evelyn Partners concluded that the CII would be unlikely to repay a loan it requested from the PFS.

A detailed email from PFS member director Vanessa Barnes, titled ‘My right to reply', and seen by COVER sister title, Professional Adviser, outlined her rebuttal of many claims made by the CII when it laid out its plans to takeover the board of the PFS last month over what it described as governance failings. Barnes said the CII had provided "no evidence to support the allegations, which I personally refute". She said: "As you have chosen to make your accusations publicly and without prior consultation or engagement, I feel I have no option but to respond accordingly to your false all...

To continue reading this article...

Join COVER for free

  • Unlimited access to real-time news, key trend analysis and industry insights.
  • Stay on top of the latest developments around health and wellbeing, diversity and inclusion and the cost of living crisis.
  • Receive breaking news stories straight to your inbox in the daily newsletter.
  • Members only access to monthly programme 'The COVER Review'
  • Be the first to hear about our CPD accredited events and awards programmes.

Join now

 

Already a Cover member?

Login

More on Regulation

John Healey's first Autumn Budget set for 28 October

John Healey's first Autumn Budget set for 28 October

Government looks to "kickstart growth in every postcode"

Isabel Baxter
clock 03 August 2026 • 2 min read
Just 12 firms recieved FCA bereavement survey: Professional Adviser

Just 12 firms recieved FCA bereavement survey: Professional Adviser

Covers advisers, platforms and wealth managers

Sophia Panayi
clock 30 July 2026 • 3 min read
FCA's Consumer Duty review finds weak focus on customer outcomes

FCA's Consumer Duty review finds weak focus on customer outcomes

Review into firms’ outcomes monitoring

Sophia Panayi
clock 27 July 2026 • 2 min read